Our best bear market advice from the first half of 2022

The first six months of 2022 were brutal for investors around the world.

Runaway inflation prompted central banks to hike interest rates and that led to worries the economy would be thrown into recession. At the same time, China’s harsh response to COVID outbreaks and the war in Ukraine compounded supply chain disruptions and economic uncertainty.

Markets around the world dropped in response. And it wasn’t just stocks. The bond market, which is supposed to be a safe harbour when the stock market turns stormy, also fell sharply in response to rapidly rising rates. 

Personal finance author Ben Carlson described the first half of 2022 as one of the worst six-month periods ever for stocks and bonds. According to Carlson, returns from a portfolio composed of 60% U.S. stocks and 40% bonds were in the bottom 2% of rolling six-months returns going back to 1926.

And those losses were mild compared to the crash in formerly high-flying speculative assets such as cryptocurrencies, non-fungible tokens and special purpose acquisition companies (SPACs). 

Over the last six months, I’ve written a series of blogs that brings together our best advice for coping with a bear market. Before we recap the highlights of those articles, let’s take a quick look at some key numbers from the fist half.

To June 30, Canadian short-term bonds were down 4.35% and the total bond market, which is the most widely followed benchmark for bonds in Canada, was down by a shocking 12.19%. It’s rare to see such negative numbers in the bond market. The last time a drop of this magnitude happened was in 1994.

Earlier in the year, Canadian stocks outperformed other international markets, thanks to the rocketing price of crude oil and other commodities. However, the Canadian market has been losing ground in recent months and ended the first half down 9.87%.  

One bright spot was large and mid-cap value stocks, which we tilt portfolios towards. In Canada, they had a year-to-date performance of 0.78% versus -20.38% for growth stocks. Small cap stocks have, however, followed the trend downward, they were -13.2%.

In the U.S., we are in bear market territory with the total market is down to June 30 by 21.1% in U.S. dollar terms and 19.4% in Canadian dollars. Here again, large and mid-cap value stocks outperformed growth at -11.01% year to date versus -26.55% for growth stocks.

It’s at times like these that it’s crucial to go back to the fundamental principles of good investing. Here are some of the core concepts I discussed in blogs in recent months that are especially relevant in the midst of a bear market.  

1. Don’t let anxiety drive your investment decisions—The illusion you can time the ups and downs of the market leads many investors to commit wealth-destroying errors. Consider what happens if you sell to avoid more losses. First, you will have to grapple with the notoriously difficult challenge of deciding when it’s safe to get back into the market and second you will risk missing out on strong returns while you’re sitting on the sidelines. Tune out the short-term noise from the media and accept that no one can forecast when the market will go up or down.

• Cultivate a long-term investor mindset—Bear markets are when investors learn their true tolerance for risk. The emotional pressure to decide and act can feel overwhelming at times. But panic almost always leads to a permanent loss of capital. That’s why it’s crucial to be mentally prepared and stick to a plan based on scientific principles. It should include broad diversification across assets and geographies and periodic rebalancing back to target allocations to position yourself to reap future returns. Louis Simpson, who managed the investment portfolio for Berkshire Hathaway’s insurance company GEICO, once said: “We do a lot of thinking and not a lot of acting. A lot of investors do a lot of acting and not a lot of thinking.” 

• Short-term pain in the bond market will lead to long-term gain—Losing money in what supposed to be your portfolio’s safe bucket is unpleasant. However, higher interest rates will lead to better bond returns in the long run. Investors, who have suffered through years of rock bottom bond returns, should want rates to rise, even if it means some capital losses in the short-term.

• Diversification is still your best strategy–It has often seemed in recent years that when trouble strikes, the markets tend to move down together. This raises the question: Does diversification still do the job it’s supposed to do: increase expected returns while reducing risk? The Credit Suisse Global Investment Returns Yearbook is a guide to historical returns for all major asset classes in 35 countries, dating back in most cases to 1900. The 2022 edition includes an examination of diversification across stocks, countries and asset classes. Among the authors conclusions is that “globalization has increased the extent to which markets move together, but the potential risk reduction benefits from international diversification remain meaningful.” They also note that international diversification is particularly important in small markets like Canada and highlight studies showing that most investors are woefully under-diversified.

A wise man once said: Expect the unexpected and you won’t be disappointed. It hasn’t been an easy time, but market history shows that the best way to ride it out is to tune out the noise, develop a long-term investor mindset and keep your focus on the fundamentals.

Be sure to check out our Capital Topics website where you will find all our podcasts and blogs to help you become a better investor.